Customers ‘shocked’ as lease dispute closes NYC pizzeria after 49 years

New York News

NEW YORK (PIX11) — It’s been a staple in the community of Bayside, Queens for nearly five decades. And soon, customers will have to savor that last slice.

Anna Sapienza, owner of Jack’s Pizza & Pasta in the Bay Terrace Open-Air Shopping Center, will have to vacate soon because her lease is not being renewed. But many in the community hope the landmark is not down for the count.

Anna feels bittersweet watching her employees work behind the counter. “Too bad it won’t be for long,” she said.

Tuesday was the first day in nearly two years that the 83-year-old stepped foot inside her second home. She’s been away due to the ongoing COVID pandemic. “All my boys are very good workers,” she said, watching her employees work. “That’s what they’re here for—to help me and make me happy.”

The pizzeria has been running since Anna’s husband, Jack Sapienza, opened it in 1972. They married in Palermo, Italy when they were young. Anna took over the place once Jack passed away 15 years ago.

Customer Debra Weinstein said she’s heartbroken by the developments. “[I’m] shocked and upset and sad,” Weinstein said. “We come here every week. This is a staple in the community.”

Anna’s daughter Laura practically grew up in the shop and claims it could have been handled differently. “It was never a moment of humanity,” Laura said. “There was never inclusiveness, which I think is what’s going wrong in the world.”

“You know what they say in Italian?” Anna asked. “The big fish eats the little fish. I’m the little fish and they’re the big fish.”

Customers are now greeted by a big yellow sign in the window informing them of their final weeks. If they’re lucky, they’ll get to reminisce with Anna, who spoke with a longtime 91-year-old customer about how he used to sit at the middle table “all the time.”

Laura said that they’ll be closing their doors sometime next month, but also said not to count them out just yet. They have something else in store—and you can bet there will be pizza.

Cord Meyer, the development company, sent a statement about the matter to NEWS10’s sister station in New York City:

“Jack’s Pizzeria has refused to meet its financial obligations. Their lease expired in September 2020, but in acknowledgment of their long history, we agreed to let them stay until the end of 2021 and offered them generous rent concessions. We are disappointed that our relationship with Jack’s has been mischaracterized. If a tenant refuses to meet agreed upon obligations, we need to focus on ensuring that the Bay Terrace remains a vibrant shopping center.”

Laura said that they were paying rent to Cord Meyer at a discounted rate because of the pandemic, but claim they agreed to eventually backpay what was missing.

Copyright 2022 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Download our news app

App Store Link
Google Play Link

Check the latest closings and delays

Latest PODCAST episode

More PODCAST: On the Story with Trishna Begam

Latest COVID-19 News

More COVID-19