ALBANY, N.Y. (NEWS10/AP/WUTR) — New Yorkers began casting ballots Saturday in elections for local and county offices in an early voting period that will run through October 31. Beyond deciding the next mayors of cities like Albany, Buffalo, and New York, people will vote on five proposed constitutional amendments, including one to create a right to clean air and water, and two that would make it easier to vote.
Early voting was first launched in the state in 2019. More than 2.5 million New Yorkers voted early in last year’s presidential election.
There are a number of key races across the Capital Region, including for mayor, county executive, and other local positions. In Albany, mayor Kathy Sheehan seeks a third term in the position against challenges from Republican Alicia Purdy, Independent Greg Aidala, and write-in candidate Valerie Faust.
Other mayoral elections include races in Saratoga Springs, Rensselaer, and Gloversville. Republican Rensselaer County Executive Steve McLaughlin wants another term, facing off against Gwen Wright.
As early voting across the state began Saturday, Gov. Kathy Hochul was in Colonie campaigning for a number of local Democratic candidates. Emergency rules during the COVID pandemic have allowed any New Yorker fearful of getting the virus to vote by mail, but that expansion could go away when the threat is over. Democrats say the voting reforms will boost turnout. Republicans have argued that New York should expand mail-in voting only if it boosts voter identification requirements.
Municipalities around the state have set up hundreds of early voting sites for this year’s contests, which include elections for school boards, district attorneys, county supervisors, and a few vacant state legislative seats. People can also vote by mail or in-person on Election Day, November 2.
One proposed constitutional change on the ballot would remove a requirement that people must register to vote at least 10 days before an election. Doing so might allow the legislature to pass a law allowing people to register the same day they cast their ballot. Voters could also remove a constitutional restriction that limits absentee voting to New Yorkers who are ill, have a physical disability, or are outside the country.
New York could also join a handful of states that have passed constitutional rights giving people the right to a clean environment. Supporters say the amendment will require the government to consider environmental effects early on in policy-making and allow New Yorkers to sue when it fails to do so.
They also say it will help fight racism in government decisions about pollution and heavy industry. Critics, including Republicans and the Lawsuit Reform Alliance of New York, say that the constitutional right will simply lead to a pile of costly lawsuits.
Another ballot measure would alter New York’s process of drawing the boundaries of congressional and legislative districts. Among other things, it would limit the number of state senators to 63 and require New York to count incarcerated people at their last place of residence, rather than the place where they are imprisoned.
It would also change some deadlines for the independent commission that is supposed to draw up nonpartisan political maps and allow lawmakers to approve those proposed maps with a simple majority vote. Currently, a two-thirds vote is required if the Assembly and Senate are controlled by the same party.
Lawmakers could also reject the commission’s maps and pass their own maps with a 60% vote. Republicans, as well as the League of Women Voters of New York State, have blasted the ballot measure for giving Democratic supermajorities too much power.
“Gerrymandering is a threat to our ability to hold meaningful and fair elections, and this proposal will undo everything voters have done to ensure that partisan political agendas do not sully our political process,” said Assemblymember Jeff Gallahan, a western New York Republican.
Utica State Sen. Joseph Griffo says the proposition would make the redistricting process partisan. Even so, this year, the independent commission at work redrawing political districts based on new census data has yet to agree on maps, submitting two completely different drafts along starkly partisan lines. That suggests lawmakers could end up drawing the lines themselves.
“The voices of the minority will be neutered completely,” said Griffo. “Now, they do have an opportunity to be involved under the current constitutional amendment that we’re under. Secondly, the vote of the legislator would be reduced from two-thirds to 60%.”
Griffo says that the proposal could allow a town or city blocks could be divided, which he describes as unfavorable to voters. “When you look at a city like Utica, you don’t want different blocks in different areas—particularly towns—you don’t want to split them in half, because there’s a commonality here,” he said. “As a region, we need to be together. We have common challenges common objectives.”
While Griffo and other Republicans urge “no” votes on proposals 1, 3, and 4, Common Cause New York, a nonprofit public advocacy group focused on good government, wants them to pass. They say the proposals would make New York’s redistricting process fairer and increase voter access.
Other Utica groups, however—like the local League of Women Voters and the Greater Utica Chamber of Commerce—also say the proposal should be voted down. “The fact that it gives the minority—it weakens their voice. We feel that it makes this not an independent process,” said Kari Puleo, the executive director of the Greater Utica Chamber of Commerce.
“All New Yorkers must be equally represented regardless of party affiliation or non-affiliation and if a single party has the ability to control the approval of these districts there’s much greater risk for gerrymandering,” said Dianne Dimeo, Vice President of the League of Women Voters.
Meanwhile, in New York City, voters will choose a successor in the state Senate for Lt. Gov. Brian Benjamin, who gave up his seat to join Gov. Kathy Hochul’s administration.